Skip to Content

How to Increase Your Restaurant’s Average Check Without Discounts

November 20, 2026 by
Pam Monteith

Most owners ask how to get more guests through the door. The guest already in the seat is the cheaper win.

I know upselling can feel pushy, and on a busy Friday none of this feels urgent. That is fair. It is a menu problem, not a people problem.

So, how do you increase your restaurant’s average check? Find the items that leave you the most after they cost you, build them into the menu as add-ons, and ask for them at the moment the guest decides. No discounts needed. Then run a seven-day test to see what worked. Remember one line along the way: sales is not profit.

Why is more sales not the same as more profit?

Because profit is what remains after food, labour, occupancy and other costs, not what comes in. A quick way to see it is contribution margin: the price of an item minus what it costs to make.

Here is an example. A $6 side that costs $2 to make leaves $4. Sell 25 more a day and that is $100 a day before other expenses. That is an illustration, not a result.

Now picture a beautiful dessert that costs most of its price to make. It can sell all night and barely move your profit. Sales is not profit.

This is why a menu full of impressive items can still leave you thin. The items that earn their place are the ones that leave you something after they cost you.

Step 1, Find: how do I find the items worth pushing?

Pull your sales, pull your item costs, and look at what gets ordered together. Then pick one item that leaves a healthy margin and pairs naturally with something guests already order. Start with one item, not the whole menu.

Your bookkeeper or accounting system can tell you the costs. The pairing is where the order gets more complete: the sandwich guests love, and the side that goes with it. Skip the items that look impressive but cost most of their price. They are great for the menu and weak for this job.

Write three things for your chosen item on one page: what it sells for, what it costs, and what it is ordered with most often. That page is your starting point.

Step 2, Build: how do I put the add-on in the menu?

Print your menu add-ons with a clear price, right where the guest is already looking. Bundles and upgrades need clear value for the guest, and they must protect your margin.

Add value, don’t subtract price. A straight discount can train guests to wait for the next deal. An upgrade or a bundle gives them a reason to say yes today. Keep it simple: one add-on, one price, next to the item it belongs with. Name it plainly. Guests decide in seconds, and a clear name with a clear price is easier to say yes to than a clever one.

Step 3, Ask: how do I ask without sounding pushy?

Give your team one line, tied to something people already order, and say it at the moment of decision. At the table, the counter or online checkout. Not after the order is in.

For example: “Most people add the house slaw with that. Want me to add one?” It is a recommendation, not pressure. Practise it once in pre-shift. If it sounds like something your team would say anyway, it is ready.

There is a signal worth knowing about. A field experiment cited in Toast’s published guide covered 2,160 transactions at two fast-food restaurants. Verbal prompts lifted side-dish sales by 16 to 18 percentage points, and they worked best when the recommended side complemented the main dish. That was a fast-food study, so treat it as a signal, not a promise. It makes a simple recommendation more likely to be worth testing in your own dining room.

What can a two-dollar lift add up to?

The same guide offers a simple example. A restaurant serving 150 guests a day, 360 days a year, that adds two dollars per guest reaches $108,000 in annual sales.

Note the word: sales, not profit. What you keep depends on the margin of what guests add, which is why Find comes first. The guide makes the same point about costs. It is an example, not a promise.

How do I test whether an add-on is working?

Pick one item and track how many sell each day for seven days. Then compare that count against the item’s margin, not just its sales. Measure covers, average check and prime cost. Not likes.

At the end of the week, ask one question: did the extra sales leave you more after costs? If yes, keep it and try the next item. If not, change the line or the price, not the guest.

You do not need more guests this week. You need a more complete order for the ones already in your seat.

At Great Work Online, I help independent restaurants get more from the marketing they already do. You can also hear this walked through in EP 24 of Great Work for Restaurants.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

How do I increase customer spend at my restaurant?

To increase your restaurant’s average check, find the items that leave you the most after their costs, print them on the menu with clear value, and have your team recommend them at the moment of decision. Start with one item and test it for seven days. Judge the result by margin, covers and average check, not sales alone.

What is contribution margin in a restaurant?

Contribution margin is an item’s price minus what it costs to make. A $6 side with $2 in ingredients leaves $4. It shows what each sale contributes toward labour, rent and other expenses, which is why it is a better guide than sales alone.

How do you upsell in a restaurant without being pushy?

Give your team one line tied to something guests already order, such as a side that pairs with a popular main. Say it at the moment of decision, not after the order is in. A short recommendation feels like service, not pressure.

Are discounts a good way to raise the average check?

Generally no. A straight discount cuts the price and can train guests to wait for the next deal. Raising the check works better through value: an upgrade, a bundle or a recommended add-on that gives the guest more and protects your margin.

How do I test whether an add-on is working?

Pick one item and track how many sell each day for seven days. Compare the count against the item’s margin, not just its sales. Watch covers, average check and prime cost. If the extra sales leave you more after costs, keep the add-on.

NEXT STEP

Book a free 30-minute Growth Session. We start with a call where you tell me how your marketing works today. Then I audit your account and digital footprint on my own and follow up with what I found, best practices, and things you can do right away. https://tidycal.com/pam-pormentilla-monteith/restaurant-growth-session

Prefer to start on your own? Download the free Toast Marketing Activation Checklist: https://greatworkonline.com/toast-activation-checklist

in Blog